Court Rejects Appeal in Medical Malpractice Case

Medical Malpractice Case

The New Jersey Appellate Division affirmed the decision of a trial court in a medical malpractice claim, finding that any error in instructing the jury had no impact on the result.

In a case involving a lawsuit filed by Sitsofe Awuku against Newark Beth Israel Center, Awuku’s lawyers argued that the jury returned an inconsistent verdict because of errors in the instructions to the jury. In a civil trial, jurors are primarily determiners of fact and are not expected to know the law. For that reason, the court will instruct the jury with respect to the law, telling them that, if they find certain facts to be true, they must make certain conclusions about the law.

In the Awuku case, the plaintiff had a pre-existing condition that was likely to lead to a stroke. The jury found that the doctors had engaged in negligence by failing to adhere to commonly accepted standards of care. They also concluded, though, that there were no recoverable damages, as the jury concluded that the injuries she suffered were the same as they would have been, had there been no negligence.

Under New Jersey law, when a patient has a pre-existing condition, any deviation from the standard of care by a treating physician will only be considered malpractice if the deviation “increased the risk of harm from the pre-existing condition.” In Awuku, the appellate court found that the breach of care by the doctors at Newark Beth Israel did not increase that risk.

Contact the Law Offices of Mallon & Tranger

To learn how we can help you if you have been the victim of sexual harassment, contact us online or call us at 732-410-6094 (toll free at 877-320-0692). There is no charge for your first meeting. We have offices in Freehold, Toms River and Point Pleasant.

Speak Your Mind


Our Office Locations


86 Court Street,
Freehold NJ 07728

Telephone: 732-780-0230
Fax: 732-780-5002

Toms River

250 Washington St
Toms River NJ 08753

Telephone: 732-780-0230
Fax: 732-780-5002

Point Pleasant

3247 Route 88
Point Pleasant NJ 08742

Telephone: 732-780-0230
Fax: 732-780-5002

Chat Banner

Can We Help You?